Part E - Section 6 - Advertising and Signage

6.1INTRODUCTION

Advertising and signage is a prominent feature of the skyline and streetscape in North Sydney. It is an integral part of the streetscape in commercial centres, shopping villages and mixed uses areas, providing information to people on business locations, products and services. However, there is also a need to ensure that signage does not dominate or detract from the character of an area.

This Section has been formulated having regard to Outdoor Advertising - An Urban Design- Based Approach produced by the NSW Department of Planning and the Victorian Department of Planning and Housing. In particular, the Section aims to maintain the characteristics of buildings, streetscapes, vistas and the significance of Sydney Harbour and to encourage well designed and carefully positioned signs that contribute to the vitality and character of North Sydney, while having regard to the amenity of residents, pedestrians and the safety of motorists.

6.1.1General Objectives

The general objectives of this Section of the DCP are to ensure that signage:

  1. 01
    is designed, sized and positioned in a consistent manner;
  2. 02
    does not detract from significant views, vistas and sensitive streetscapes;
  3. 03
    adds character to the streetscape and complements the architectural style and use of buildings;
  4. 04
    minimises visual clutter or environmental degradation through proliferation;
  5. 05
    minimises the potential for adverse impacts on sky glow from the illumination of signs;
  6. 06
    conveys the advertiser's messages or images without causing an adverse social impact upon the community; and
  7. 07
    Minimises impacts upon the safety of drivers and pedestrians.

6.1.2When does this section of the DCP apply?

This Section of the DCP applies to all development applications incorporating signage that can be seen from a public place such as a street, waterway or public reserve. Some types of signage are also permitted without development consent (refer to Part 2 of SEPP (Exempt and Complying Development Codes) 2008).

6.1.3Relationship to other documents and planning policies

Where relevant, this Section of the DCP needs to be read in conjunction with the following:

  1. (a)
    Chapter 3 – Advertising and Signage to SEPP (Industry and Employment) 2021

    The SEPP contains specific provisions relating to all forms of signage. Applications for all forms of signage, must give consideration to Parts 3.1, 3.2 and Divisions 1 and 2 to Part 3.3 and Schedule 5 of the SEPP. Applications for signage, other than building or business identification signs or signage which is exempt development, are also required consider the provisions of Division 3 to Part 3.3 and Part 3.4 of the SEPP.

  2. (b)
    Transport Corridor Outdoor Advertising and Signage Guidelines

    This Guideline is required to be considered where signage is proposed to be located on Transport Corridor land as identified under SEPP (Industry and Employment) 2021.

  3. (c)
    Building Code of Australia (BCA)

    Part B of the BCA contains provisions dealing with dead and live loads, load combinations and wind loads which may have an impact the way a proposed sign is designed and affixed to a building or site.

  4. (d)
    Australian Standard AS 4282 Control of the Obtrusive Effects of Outdoor Lighting

    This Standard contains relevant guidelines for external illumination devices providing recommended limits for the relevant lighting parameters to contain obtrusive illumination effects within tolerable levels.

6.2ADVERTISING DESIGN ANALYSIS

The following advertising design analysis aims to provide guidance on desirable forms of advertising in North Sydney for different zones and areas. Advertising design should reinforce the character of advertising described in this analysis.

6.2.1E1 Local Centre Zone

  1. (a)
    Waverton, Cammeray, Kirribilli, Blues Point Road

    These areas consist mainly of one and two storey buildings with shops at ground floor level that serve the local needs of the community and some shop top housing above. Existing signage is predominantly limited to small scale business identification signs mostly consisting of fascia, under awning (some illuminated), top hamper and window signs. There are no large scale advertisements given the limited scale of the built form. The existing character of these villages should be retained by limiting signage to small scale business identification signs in the forms previously described.

6.2.2MU1 Mixed Use Zone

  1. (a)
    Milson's Point

    Milsons Point has a diverse range of land uses including residential, commercial and retail that are mostly located in multi storey buildings that have a prominent location on the foreshores of Sydney Harbour. Signage in Milsons Point predominantly comprises a mixture of small business identification signs (mostly consisting of fascia, under awning, wall and projecting wall signs). There are some limited larger wall and roof signs on building elevations that are quite visible from Sydney Harbour. To enhance the views of North Sydney from Sydney Harbour and the Bradfield Highway, future signage should be limited to small scale business and/or building identification signs at lower levels where commercial development is permitted under NSLEP 2013.

  2. (b)
    Crows Nest

    Crows Nest is a lively, interesting main street shopping village that is predominately two storey in scale to Willoughby Road and increasing in scale as it approaches the Pacific Highway, with mostly retail shops and cafes at ground level. Current signage is predominantly limited to small scale business identification signs (mostly consisting of under awning, fascia, projecting wall and window signs). There are, however, three large roof signs at the major intersection of Falcon Street, Shirley Road and the Pacific Highway that have an adverse impact upon the streetscape. For this reason, further large and/or roof signs are discouraged in the Crows Nest area. Signage in the Crows Nest Village should remain small scale especially along Willoughby Road where there is a small scale village atmosphere and along Pacific Highway where the traditional two storey parapet shopfront is a dominate feature. Above awning signs on traditional shop frontages should be avoided to enhance the character of the Crows Nest Village Centre.

  3. (c)
    St Leonards

    St Leonards has been rezoned from a former commercial and industrial area to mixed use and commercial. There are a number of large existing roof and wall signs that currently dominate the skyline, so any additional signage of this type should be avoided. Signage in

this area should be limited to small scale business identification advertisements at the ground level (mostly consisting of under awning, fascia and top hamper signs) and no new larger illuminated wall and roof signs at upper levels.

  1. (d)
    Cremorne and Neutral Bay

    The built form in the Cremorne and Neutral Bay villages is generally two-five storeys with small shops located at ground level. Signage is predominantly limited to small scale business identification signs (mostly consisting of under awning, fascia, top hamper, window and projecting wall signs). There are two undesirable forms of signage that have an adverse impact on the streetscape including a bridge sign located on the pedestrian link to SCEGS Redlands and a large wall sign on Military Road near Wycombe Road. Future signage should, therefore, be limited to small scale business identification signs at the ground floor level to promote commercial activity in the area.

6.2.3E3 Productivity Support Zone

  1. (a)
    McMahons Point

    This area is a mixture of modern two or three storey commercial buildings amidst one or two storey historic terrace houses and timber or stone cottages. Most of the non-residential uses in McMahons Point provide support services for businesses located in the North Sydney Centre such as advertising agencies, printers, graphic designers and publishers. Existing signage is mostly small business or building identification signs mostly consisting of fascia and illuminated under awning signage. There is no large scale signage within the Productivity Support zone, with signage limited in number and scale and subdued to preserve the partially residential character of the area. Small scale business identification signage is the desired level of advertising for this area.

6.2.4North Sydney Centre

North Sydney Centre is a vibrant, prosperous commercial centre consisting mainly of multi storey commercial buildings. The area is well serviced with community facilities such as North Sydney Oval, the Stanton Library and the Civic Centre Park and the Don Bank Museum. Within the North Sydney Centre are two conservation areas (McLaren Street and Walker Street) that contain significant landmarks such as St Thomas Church and the Council Chambers.

Signage within the North Sydney Centre is diverse with a number of large illuminated wall and roof business identification signs that dominate the skyline. In addition to larger advertisements, there are numerous small scale business identification signs at the street level (mostly consisting of under awning, window, top hamper, free standing, fascia and projecting wall signs).

The visual impact of the larger illuminated roof and wall signs in the North Sydney Centre is significant given their prominent location on the shores of Sydney Harbour and their close proximity to Bradfield Highway. To enhance views from Sydney Harbour, large business identification wall signs on multi storey buildings above first floor level should be limited to no more than two per building and must be incorporated into the overall design of the building. Generally, additional signage should be limited to small scale business identification signs at the ground floor level to convey messages to potential customers in preference to large scale roof and/or sky signs.

6.3FAÇADE GRID ANALYSIS

This is a simple technique that can be used to:

  1. (a)
    comprehensively identify sign opportunities for inclusion by the council in any more detailed development control plan for specific precincts;
  2. (b)
    identify appropriate sign opportunities for developers and occupants; and
  3. (c)
    assess specific development applications for signs.

While the technique relates specifically to traditional building facades (such as those commonly found in strip- shopping centres), the principles can be applied to all building forms.

Signage does not necessarily have to be placed on a building's front facade. For example, they can be placed on side-walls provided they do not interfere with the adjoining development. In these circumstances the principles of the technique still apply.

The technique is set out in the four steps below.

STEP 1:STEP 1:

To identify sign opportunities, subdivide the building's facade along its main design lines to form a series of panels. Many traditional building designs can be easily broken into a grid based on the alignments of the parapet (skyline), cornice, verandah, window and door. An example of this procedure is shown in Figure E-6.1.

Figure E-6.1: Establishing a façade-grid

STEP 2:STEP 2:

To identify possible signage locations, the rectangles of the grid may be used separately or be joined together to form horizontal or vertical panels (refer to Figure E-6.2).

The scale of advertising signs should be compatible with the buildings they are on, as well as with nearby buildings, street widths and other existing signs. In most cases appropriate dimensions are achieved by restricting signs to grid locations or panels. This ensures that the original architectural character (set by the lines of awnings, window and door openings, parapet lines and setbacks) remains dominant.

On buildings with decorative facades, signs should not be placed on the decorative forms or mouldings. Instead, they should appear on the undecorated wall surfaces, unless architecturally-designed sign panels are provided.

Figure E-6.2 also shows that a building may be given a horizontal or vertical appearance simply by the way in which the sign panels are arranged across or down a building.

Figure E-6.2: Horizontal or vertical panels

STEP 3:STEP 3:

Applying the technique to a series of buildings also illustrates the possible panels for the streetscape and provides the basis for developing patterns and themes for a group of buildings and or tenancies.

Figure E-6.3: Developing patterns and themes
Figure E-6.4: Improving discontinuities in streetscapes

Figure E-6.3 shows how the technique produces a uniform and clean series of sign possibilities instead of a haphazard array. It also shows that sign panels do not have to be

rectilinear in design or contained in a perimeter margin unless these impose an architectural formality or introduce a continuity with the surrounding area which is presently lacking in the building.

Figure E-6.4 shows how a variation of the technique can be used to help correct discontinuities in streetscape. The lines of adjacent buildings may be projected across the facade of the building, thereby defining horizontal panels in which signs may be located. This will achieve visual continuity with neighbouring buildings.

STEP 4:STEP 4:

Not every panel identified using this technique should be used to display a sign. The number and size of signs proposed is determined by provisions contained in the remaining parts of this Section of the DCP. In deciding which of the panels is the appropriate space for advertising, the following matters should also be considered:

  1. (a)
    the number and location of existing signs;
  2. (b)
    the quality of the streetscape; and
  3. (c)
    the objectives and provisions of this Section of the DCP.

6.4GENERAL CONTROLS - DESIGN, SCALE AND SIZE

ObjectivesObjectives

  1. O1
    To ensure that signage does not detract from the architecture of existing buildings, streetscapes and vistas.

ProvisionsProvisions

  1. P1
    Signage attached to buildings is to be designed, scaled and sized having regard to a façade grid analysis.
  2. P2
    Where practical signage not attached to buildings must be designed to have regard to the size, height and scale of nearby buildings and their elements.
  3. P3
    Signage should be visually interesting and integrated with the architecture of the building.
  4. P4
    Lettering, materials and colours should be used that complement the existing building or place.
  5. P5
    Signage must not dominate the building or site to which it is attached.
  6. P6
    Do not locate signage where it will obstruct views, vistas or cause significant overshadowing.
  7. P7
    Signage must not dominate the skyline or protrude above any parapet or eaves.
  8. P8
    Signage must not cover any window, other opening or significant architectural features of the building.
  9. P9
    The proposed means of fixture to the building or any support structure for freestanding signs must be consistent with the relevant character statement in Section 6.2.
  10. P10
    Avoid freestanding signs that dominate the skyline when viewed from the ground within one kilometre.

6.5LOCATION

ObjectivesObjectives

  1. O1
    To establish a consistent approach to the positioning of signage and to enhance the streetscape.